Play Nice to Win Big

Play Nice to Win Big

November 20, 2026

We were told for years that winning motivated people. Add points and a leaderboard, watch engagement soar. But reality never quite matched the promise.

Bing Gordon and Chloe Gordon, writing in Fast Company, say “gamification” can be more hype than real results when it copies the wrong thing. Bing spent decades in the video game industry, and he says successful games rarely run on competition. They run on cooperation. While winning feels good, the games that keep players coming back excel at social connection, personal mastery, and productivity.

Consider a blast from the past: Farmville. The app notifications inviting friends to play together drew about 30 times the clicks of the competitive, brag-style ones. LinkedIn’s endorsements let colleagues vouch for each other, giving people a reason to return even when not job hunting. Scores and levels work best tracking your own progress rather than ranking against others. We’ve seen it in our own learning products: team competitions outperform individual ones, because players are really cooperating with teammates while competing with rivals. The shouts are louder and the smiles are a little bigger.

People don’t return for the points. They return for each other, and for products that leave them feeling better than they started. Build for that, and the engagement will follow.